Blog / Hooks and short-form
Why your reels get no views, and the order I check them in
Most advice on this question starts with the hook. The hook matters, and I will get to it, but it is the fourth thing I check, not the first. When a client sends me a reel with a few dozen views and asks what went wrong, the answer is usually something that happened before anyone watched a second of it: the reel was never shown to a new audience at all, or it was shown to fewer people because of how the file was made.
Instagram has published more about how this works than most people realise. What follows is the order I check things in, with the platform's own pages linked so you can read the source rather than take my word for it.
How a reel finds people who don't follow you
Start with the mechanism, because every fix below follows from it.
In April 2024 Instagram described the system it was rolling out for recommended reels. Every piece of eligible content is first shown to a small audience that the platform predicts will enjoy it, whether or not those people follow you. If that group engages, the best performers go to a slightly wider group, then a wider one again. Instagram's definition of eligible in that same post: original, within the community guidelines, no visible watermarks, and inside the recommendation guidelines.
So a reel with no views has failed at one of two gates. Either it never got into the first test, or it got in and the test audience moved on. Those are different problems with different fixes, and treating the second when you have the first wastes weeks.
Check 1: is the reel, or the whole account, eligible?
Instagram keeps a separate, stricter set of rules for content it recommends to people who don't follow you. Its help centre says these Recommendations Guidelines are held to a higher standard than the community standards. That makes sense when you think about it: recommended content comes from accounts the viewer never chose. A reel can break them without breaking any rule that gets it removed. It stays up, your followers can still see it, and nobody else will.
The part that surprises people is the account-level penalty. Adam Mosseri's ranking explainer says that if an account repeatedly posts content that goes against these guidelines, none of its posts will be eligible for recommendation for a period of time. A run of borderline posts can quietly hold back the ones that follow.
What to do: open Account Status in the app's settings. Instagram points to it as the place to see whether your account and content can be recommended, and to appeal anything that has been flagged.
For a small business, the categories that catch people off guard are the commercial ones. Instagram's 2024 refresher on these guidelines lists content promoting cosmetic procedures, exaggerated health claims and certain regulated products among the categories that may not be recommended. A clinic promoting a procedure, a supplement reel with a big health claim, or a vape shop showing its products can do everything else right and still post into a wall.
Check 2: the six things Instagram says it shows less of
This is the most useful paragraph Instagram has published for anyone making reels, and it is easy to miss. In its ranking explainer, Instagram says it aims to make certain reels less visible, naming:
- Low-resolution reels. In my experience, usually the result of a file sent through a messaging app before it was posted, which recompresses it. Post from the original file on the phone that filmed it.
- Watermarked reels. The classic case is a reel made in another app and downloaded with that app's logo burned into the corner. Export a clean version or post the original.
- Muted reels. A reel with no sound at all. As I read it, even a quiet music bed under silent footage counts as sound; a dead track does not.
- Reels with borders. A horizontal video dropped into a vertical frame with black or blurred bars above and below. It reads as a repost from somewhere else, which is likely why it is on the list.
- Reels that are mostly text. A quote card or a list of tips held on screen as a reel. If the idea works as text, it is a carousel, not a reel.
- Reels already posted on Instagram. Re-uploading the same reel because the first one flopped. Make a new edit instead: a different first frame, a different first line, a different length.
In my experience, at least one of these is the answer far more often than the hook is. Borders and watermarks are the two I see most from small businesses, because both come from reusing a video made for somewhere else.
Check 3: length, and the three-minute line
Instagram lets you post reels up to 20 minutes long, but its help page on recording a reel adds a short note: reels over three minutes won't be recommended to new audiences. A long reel will still reach your followers. It will not be offered to anyone else.
If your goal is reach, the reel needs to come in under that line, and in practice well under it. A three-minute reel has to hold a stranger for three minutes, and the test audience in the first gate is made of strangers. If you have three minutes of good material, it is usually two or three reels, or a long-form video with short clips cut from it. The post on hiring an editor covers how to tell an editor which platform each piece is for.
Check 4: did the test audience stay?
Only now is it worth looking at the hook. If the reel was eligible, clean and the right length, and it still stalled, the first audience did not engage with it.
Instagram names what it is predicting for reels. The most important predictions, it says, are how likely a viewer is to reshare a reel, watch it all the way through, like it, and go to the audio page. Two of those four are about the reel being finished and passed on, not tapped and scrolled past.
That shifts the question from "was the hook clever?" to "did the first two seconds tell a stranger what they would get for staying?" Some things I check on a stalled reel:
- The first frame. Is something already happening, or is it a person settling into frame before they speak? The settle costs you the viewer.
- The first line. Does it name a specific problem or result the viewer recognises, or does it start with your name and business?
- The middle. Is there a stretch where nothing changes on screen for four or five seconds? That is where the watch-through prediction is lost.
- The end. Does the reel stop when the point is made, or does it trail into a sign-off? A clean stop is what makes a full watch possible.
Most of these are decided before the edit, at the moment of filming. For framing and takes that give the editor a usable first frame, see how to film a reel on your phone.
Check 5: is it original?
The 2024 changes also dealt with copies. When Instagram finds two or more identical pieces of content, it says it will only recommend the original one, and accounts that repeatedly post content they didn't create or materially change can be removed from recommendations altogether.
For a business this rarely means stealing. It means reposting a supplier's product video, a creator's review of your product exactly as they posted it, or a trending clip with your logo on top. Instagram's help page describes the problem as unoriginal content repurposed from another source with only minor, immaterial edits. Adding your own voiceover, a reaction or a real re-edit is a different thing; dropping a caption on top of someone else's reel is not.
If a creator made a video about you that you want on your account, ask them to make you a version, or use it as raw footage in a reel you edit yourself.
Where I fit: A lot of my month is spent on checks 2 to 4 before a reel ever goes out: clean exports, no borders, a first frame with something already moving, and an end that stops on time. If your reels keep stalling at the same place, Book a call and bring the one that hurt most.
A fifteen-minute diagnosis for your last ten reels
Put your last ten reels side by side and answer these, in order, for each one:
- Is anything flagged in Account Status under recommendations?
- Does the reel have any of the six: low resolution, a watermark, no sound, borders, mostly text, posted before?
- Is it over three minutes?
- Is something happening in the first frame, and does the first line name what the viewer gets?
- Is it yours, or substantially someone else's?
Patterns show up fast. If the reels that died all share one answer, that is your fix, and it is usually a production habit, not a creative one. If none of them trip checks 1 to 3 and they still stall, the work is in the first two seconds and the middle, which is editing, and that is good news, because editing is the part you can change next week.