Blog / Long-form and editing
How to convert horizontal video to vertical, and what will not survive the crop
Every tool that promises to turn your landscape video into a reel does the same thing underneath. It cuts a tall, narrow window out of the wide frame and throws the rest away. The tools differ in how cleverly they move that window. None of them can bring back what is outside it.
So the useful question is not which converter to use. It is what fits inside the window, and what to do with the shots that do not. I cut reels and Shorts out of podcasts, interviews and YouTube videos every month, and this is the decision I make shot by shot.
The maths of a 16:9 to 9:16 crop
A horizontal frame is 16:9. A reel or a Short is 9:16. If you keep the full height of the horizontal frame and cut a vertical slice out of it, the slice is 9/16 of the height wide, which works out at a little under a third of the original width (about 31.6%).
In pixels, that is what decides the quality.
- From 1080p (1920 by 1080), the vertical slice is about 608 pixels wide and 1080 tall. To fill a 1080 by 1920 vertical frame, it has to be scaled up by roughly 1.8 times. That is where the soft, smeary look comes from.
- From 4K (3840 by 2160), the slice is about 1,215 pixels wide and 2,160 tall. That is larger than a 1080 by 1920 frame, so it scales down, not up, and stays sharp.
That arithmetic is the whole argument for filming in 4K even when the main video goes out in 1080p. The extra pixels are what you crop into later. If your long-form footage is 1080p, you can still make vertical clips; just expect them to look softer, and keep the crop as loose as the shot allows.
What survives the crop
The shots that convert well have one thing in common: the subject already sits near the middle third of the frame, and nothing important happens at the edges.
- One person talking to camera, framed in the centre. The classic YouTube talking head converts almost perfectly.
- A single speaker in a podcast, on their own camera angle. If each person has their own camera, each angle is a clean single and crops well.
- Close-ups and inserts: hands on a product, a face reacting, a detail on a desk. These were already tight, so the narrow window loses little.
- Shots where the subject moves slowly. A crop that has to chase fast movement across the frame looks nervous. Slow movement can be followed smoothly.
What does not, and the four fixes
Four kinds of shot fail the crop almost every time. Each has a better answer than a hopeful auto-reframe.
1. The wide two-shot. Two people at a table, one on the left third, one on the right. A vertical window can hold one of them, never both. The fix is to cut between them: crop to whoever is speaking and switch the window when the speaker changes, on the cut, not with a slide across the frame. If the reaction matters as much as the line, use a split layout with one person stacked above the other, each in their own crop.
2. Slides, screen recordings and on-screen text. A slide designed for a wide frame does not fit a narrow one, and titles or lower thirds burned into the long-form get sliced in half. The fix is to rebuild them: put the speaker in the vertical frame and recreate the one line from the slide as a new caption sized for a phone. Keep it clear of the interface. Meta's guidance for reels ads suggests leaving at least 14% of the top, 35% of the bottom and 6% on each side free of text and important elements; that is written for ads, but the app draws the same buttons over an organic reel, so I use it as my guide for both.
3. Wide establishing shots and camera moves. A slow pan across a room, a drone shot of the building, a reveal from left to right. In a narrow window the pan becomes a blur of shapes. Cut them, or replace them with a still detail from the same place. A vertical clip rarely needs an establishing shot anyway; it needs a face in the first second.
4. Demonstrations that use the whole width. Someone walks from one side of the frame to the other, or lays out products across a table. Either follow them with a crop that moves slowly and steadily, or accept that this shot needs to be filmed again, vertically. Some shots are cheaper to reshoot than to rescue.
What I avoid is the letterbox: the whole horizontal frame shrunk into the middle of a vertical one, with a title above and blank space below. It keeps everything and shows nothing; the subject ends up a third of the size, and in my experience it reads instantly as a repost from somewhere else.
Moving the window: the part that makes it look edited
The difference between a converted clip and an edited one is how the window moves.
- Reframe on the cut, not during the shot. When the speaker changes, cut to a new crop. Do not slide the window sideways in view of the audience unless you are deliberately following movement.
- Keep the eyes on the same line. Set the crop so the speaker's eyes sit around the top third of the vertical frame, and keep that height consistent from crop to crop. Jumping eye lines are the clearest sign of a lazy conversion.
- Leave air above the head, and keep the chin out of the caption zone. The bottom of a reel is where captions and the app's own interface live.
- Check the auto-reframe, every time. Most editing apps now have a tool that tracks a face and moves the window for you. It is a fine first pass. It is also confidently wrong whenever two faces are in shot or the speaker turns away, so I treat its result as a draft and correct it shot by shot.
Where I fit: this is most of what "clips cut from the long-form" means in a monthly slate. I pick the moments, reframe them shot by shot, rebuild the text for a phone and add captions in your brand, so one recording feeds the month's video slate. If you record long-form already, Book a call.
YouTube's own Shorts tool, and its limits
If your long-form is already on YouTube, there is a built-in route. YouTube's help page describes Edit into a Short: from the watch page of your own public video, you select up to 60 seconds, choose a layout and publish. The Short links back to the original video, which is the real advantage, because new viewers have a path to the full episode. The same page notes you cannot add music or sounds from YouTube's Audio Library to a Short made this way.
It is quick and good enough for a test. For a clip you want to perform, I still prefer the edit: more control over the crop, the opening line and the captions, and the freedom to export the same clip for Instagram too. YouTube's upload page says a Short uploaded from a computer can be up to 3 minutes with a square or vertical aspect ratio, so a clip edited elsewhere has room to breathe. Instagram allows reels up to 20 minutes, but says reels over 3 minutes will not be recommended to new audiences, so I keep clips meant for discovery well under that.
Film the long-form so it crops later
The cheapest conversion is the one you plan for when you film. If you record long-form you intend to clip, a few habits make every vertical cut easier.
- Film in 4K, for the pixel reason above, even if the long-form goes out in 1080p.
- One camera per person on a podcast or interview, or at least frame each person so they could be cropped on their own.
- Keep each speaker near the centre of their own frame, not pushed to the edge for a wide composition you will only use once.
- Leave headroom. A tight horizontal frame leaves nowhere to move the vertical window up or down.
- Keep text out of the camera original. Add titles in the edit, where they can be rebuilt for each shape, instead of filming a whiteboard or a screen you will later need to read on a phone.
That is a short list, but it changes the conversion from rescue work into a routine. For a business that records one long video a week, in my experience it is the difference between about three usable clips and ten. If you are about to hand that work to someone, how to hire a video editor covers what to send them.